[ View Thread ] [ Post Response ] [ Return to Index ] [ Read Prev Msg ] [ Read Next Msg ]

RUC20 Evaluation Discussion Board

Re: Tmax OBS vs MODEL comparison

Posted By: Jack Glendening
Date: 14-September-02 2132Z

In Response To: Re: Tmax OBS vs MODEL comparison (John M. Brown)

The discrepancy is easily explained - I can't count (data columns, at least). The plot that had been displayed was of the
2m temperature vs the grid bottom temperature - I have now replaced it with a corrected version. Color me embarassed as I should have been suspicious since the plot scatter was less than I had expected from looking at the numbers - and I never thought to check the sign of the offset. Perhaps I can atone by providing an additional graph which compares the model error to daily temperature changes, i.e.to the change in temperature from the previous day, which might be viewed a comparison to the "persistence" prediction, at
www.drjack.net/BLIPMAP/obschange_vs_2m-obs_tmax.hernandez.png
Also, the mintopo height is within 3m of the model terrain and both are below the actual (ridge) observation height.

Messages In This Thread

Tmax OBS vs MODEL comparison -- Jack Glendening -- 13-September-02 0204Z
Re: Tmax OBS vs MODEL comparison -- Stan Benjamin -- 4-September-02 1652Z
Re: Tmax OBS vs MODEL comparison -- Jack Glendening -- 7-September-02 0147Z
Re: Tmax OBS vs MODEL comparison -- Stan Benjamin -- 7-September-02 0147Z
Re: Tmax OBS vs MODEL comparison -- John M. Brown -- 13-September-02 0628Z
Re: Tmax OBS vs MODEL comparison -- Jack Glendening -- 14-September-02 2132Z
Re: Tmax OBS vs MODEL comparison -- John M. Brown -- 14-September-02 2132Z

[ View Thread ] [ Post Response ] [ Return to Index ] [ Read Prev Msg ] [ Read Next Msg ]

RUC20 Evaluation Discussion Board is maintained by RUC/MAPS Forum Administrators with WebBBS 5.12.